What I could dig up on coalition governments (google AI, take with a grain of doubt)
Yes, a coalition government can legally form in the Canadian Parliament, though it is extremely rare at the federal level. It requires two or more parties to agree to form a government together, sharing Cabinet seats to hold a majority in the House of Commons. While possible, parties usually prefer informal agreements to a formal coalition.
Although frequently considered as a possibility during minority situations, a formal, multi-party Cabinet coalition has not existed in federal politics in over a century.
- Definition & Structure: A formal coalition requires members from different parties to sit in Cabinet together, allowing them to command the majority support needed to govern.
- Legitimacy: Coalition governments are legally valid within Canada’s parliamentary democracy, although rarely seen in federal politics.
- Historical Context: The only formal federal coalition was the 1917 Union Government led by Sir Robert Borden.
- 2008–09 Case: In 2008, the Liberal Party and NDP planned a coalition supported by the Bloc Québécois to challenge a Conservative government, but it did not come to fruition.
- Minority vs. Coalition: Many federal governments are minority governments—where the governing party has the most seats but not a majority—relying on agreements with other parties rather than sharing power in a formal coalition
Now my thoughts. That is a rare beast indeed. Just imagine any 2 parties actually cooperating enough to achieve this? As stated, very rare.
The Justin-Jagmeet Pact was not actually a coalition government although it essentially created the same effect. In the end, look at what voters said to Jagmeet for essentially propping up the Liberals (yes there are a multitude of reasons of why but the biggest I see is this combined with scary orange man bad)
You look at the four party leaders (I assume a best case scenario for Avi and the NDP), it would be pretty fragile coalition if any two of them cooperated.
And it would still not require anyone to leave their party.
Yeah, but I wasn't talking about a coalition. What I described doesn't require that; merely that the leader of one of the parties convince the GG they can maintain confidence in the house in lieu of going ot an election when the other guy loses same.
Yes, a coalition obviously would be a way to do that, but a simple supply and confidence agreement like we've seen in the pat would suffice as well. Naturally the now-opposition and all the Twitter pundits would absolutely lose their minds screaming about it being an 'unelected coalition', like they did with the LPC/NDP S&C agreement, but a coalition is generally distinguished by both (all) members having some representation in cabinet.
Anyway- the situation I describe would require a particular set of circumstances starting with a weak minority outnumbered by two or more other parties that could cooperate and have the 50%+1 seats necessary to pull it off. So, rare to have that opportunity. But if it happened? Totally legit.
