• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
What I could dig up on coalition governments (google AI, take with a grain of doubt)
Yes, a coalition government can legally form in the Canadian Parliament, though it is extremely rare at the federal level. It requires two or more parties to agree to form a government together, sharing Cabinet seats to hold a majority in the House of Commons. While possible, parties usually prefer informal agreements to a formal coalition.
  • Definition & Structure: A formal coalition requires members from different parties to sit in Cabinet together, allowing them to command the majority support needed to govern.
  • Legitimacy: Coalition governments are legally valid within Canada’s parliamentary democracy, although rarely seen in federal politics.
  • Historical Context: The only formal federal coalition was the 1917 Union Government led by Sir Robert Borden.
  • 2008–09 Case: In 2008, the Liberal Party and NDP planned a coalition supported by the Bloc Québécois to challenge a Conservative government, but it did not come to fruition.
  • Minority vs. Coalition: Many federal governments are minority governments—where the governing party has the most seats but not a majority—relying on agreements with other parties rather than sharing power in a formal coalition
Although frequently considered as a possibility during minority situations, a formal, multi-party Cabinet coalition has not existed in federal politics in over a century.

Now my thoughts. That is a rare beast indeed. Just imagine any 2 parties actually cooperating enough to achieve this? As stated, very rare.

The Justin-Jagmeet Pact was not actually a coalition government although it essentially created the same effect. In the end, look at what voters said to Jagmeet for essentially propping up the Liberals (yes there are a multitude of reasons of why but the biggest I see is this combined with scary orange man bad)

You look at the four party leaders (I assume a best case scenario for Avi and the NDP), it would be pretty fragile coalition if any two of them cooperated.

And it would still not require anyone to leave their party.

Yeah, but I wasn't talking about a coalition. What I described doesn't require that; merely that the leader of one of the parties convince the GG they can maintain confidence in the house in lieu of going ot an election when the other guy loses same.

Yes, a coalition obviously would be a way to do that, but a simple supply and confidence agreement like we've seen in the pat would suffice as well. Naturally the now-opposition and all the Twitter pundits would absolutely lose their minds screaming about it being an 'unelected coalition', like they did with the LPC/NDP S&C agreement, but a coalition is generally distinguished by both (all) members having some representation in cabinet.

Anyway- the situation I describe would require a particular set of circumstances starting with a weak minority outnumbered by two or more other parties that could cooperate and have the 50%+1 seats necessary to pull it off. So, rare to have that opportunity. But if it happened? Totally legit.
 
Or they may feel that LPC will offer them more opportunity to make a difference for the next three years.
Is this a similar argument to Jagmeet's "positioning himself as kingmaker and getting what he wanted out of the government"? In the end, look at the cost his party paid for his abandoning his values. The cost to be part of the government may be quite high for both individual MPs and possibly the Liberal Party.
 
Is this a similar argument to Jagmeet's "positioning himself as kingmaker and getting what he wanted out of the government"? In the end, look at the cost his party paid for his abandoning his values. The cost to be part of the government may be quite high for both individual MPs and possibly the Liberal Party.
Indeed.

We are back to the voter, ultimately, rewarding or punishing behaviours.

Jagmeet and the NDP took all of the risk and got none of the reward for propping up the Trudeau version of the Liberals. The NDP core voters obviously saw it as a betrayal of their values and stayed away from them in droves last election. And it did not attract voters from the Liberal or CPC camps.

I personally think Jagmeet was woefully naive.
 
Is this a similar argument to Jagmeet's "positioning himself as kingmaker and getting what he wanted out of the government"? In the end, look at the cost his party paid for his abandoning his values. The cost to be part of the government may be quite high for both individual MPs and possibly the Liberal Party.
Sure, and my speculation was wrong on that one… Like many, my best guesses were overcome by larger events and some misread on my part.

I think it’s a somewhat easier call to say that crossing MPs entering a majority government will have more opportunity to make a direct
impact on government policy than if they stayed with a now-neutered opposition.

Maybe I’m wrong on that too. The fact remains that the LPC now have a majority government, and some MPs have chosen to join it from across the floor. Each will have done their own assessment, likely better informed than any of ours.
 
Indeed.

We are back to the voter, ultimately, rewarding or punishing behaviours.

Jagmeet and the NDP took all of the risk and got none of the reward for propping up the Trudeau version of the Liberals. The NDP core voters obviously saw it as a betrayal of their values and stayed away from them in droves last election. And it did not attract voters from the Liberal or CPC camps.

I personally think Jagmeet was woefully naive.

I think our disagreement is when exactly the voters should get their say.
 
For readers who may be interested in discussing it, the 12 April, 2026 , 338 Canada Federal Projection , if an election were held today ,

And yet PM Carney appears uninterested in calling an election to lock in a very solid majority, with a timer reset for the next four years, that would mute the criticisms about gaining a majority through floor crossings. Anyone accusing him of political cynicism and opportunism should take note of that. He appears more interested in keeping Parliament functioning and working with what he's got.
 
And yet PM Carney appears uninterested in calling an election to lock in a very solid majority, with a timer reset for the next four years, that would mute the criticisms about gaining a majority through floor crossings. Anyone accusing him of political cynicism and opportunism should take note of that. He appears more interested in keeping Parliament functioning and working with what he's got.
Part of what makes him popular is that he is seen as being serious about getting things done, and not playing silly political games. If he called an election to get a majority, when he is not having issues getting things done as it is, he would play in the CPC's hands. It would be easy to paint him as just like Trudeau calling an unnecessary/unwanted election because he was up in the polls.
 
Exactly. Now he can remain willfully ignorant while Carney can willfully ignore it. Certainly Poilievres is the greater sin.
While I agree that the CO who knows of fucksters in the battalion and seems to do nothing about them is bad, we'll have to agree to disagree on the badness of the CO who refuses to hear about any potential fucksters in the battalion so he can remain "willfully ignorant" AND not have to explain what he's doing about them while berating other battalions about their fucksters.
 
The non apology DWAN wide email really landed flat.

I have no fundamental issue with people getting an opportunity to apply for a job that they found out about because of who they know, but from the ethics commissionaire report she essentially pushed him to be hired for something he was woefully unqualified for, and got let go due to performance issues (and somehow landed in the PCO).

Given the completely unexperienced PMs that are getting hired and thrown at complex projects, and doing okay, I can't imagine how bad you would have to shit the bed to get let go in the public service, so that's not great.

Especially when there are a lot of qualified people from pretty diverse backgrounds that would have ticked those same boxes, they just didn't know the DM, it's pretty frustrating. Already hard enough to hire people that it's frustrating that someone high enough was able to push that through, knowing all the hoops I have to jump through to hire people with years of experience.
 
Not an HR SME.

But, read this,

Canadian federal public service, the Executive (EX) Group consists of senior leaders (EX-01 to EX-05) responsible for managing major programs, policies, and resources.

Job Security and Termination: Executives in the core public administration have more limited job security than unionized, employees.


I recall that was certainly the case in the muni PS.
 
Back
Top