• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
Carney is showing us running Canada is a business. Politics based in ideology is going by the way side. There's benefits to that. It's also going to come with a healthy dose of be quiet, pay your taxes, and mind your own business.

Is that a good idea though? Running government as a business? I recall a certain politician south of us being accused of doing that and being roundly pillored for it. Or is it just a difference in styles? I'm not looking to turn this into a tangent, just looking for a quick explanation. Politics or business. I think there should be a hybrid between the two.
 
Is that a good idea though? Running government as a business? I recall a certain politician south of us being accused of doing that and being roundly pillored for it. Or is it just a difference in styles? I'm not looking to turn this into a tangent, just looking for a quick explanation. Politics or business. I think there should be a hybrid between the two.
because the guy down south runs things like he ran his business not like a business
 
because the guy down south runs things like he ran his business not like a business

But his businesses are businesses and they've made him a billionaire worth between 6 - 7 billion, according to Forbes and Bloomberg.

If anyone wishes to give real answers to my questions, I'll wait. You can even just PM me as to not clog this thread up. Otherwise back to Rogan/ Poliviere.
 
Probably but point is people are digging everything to jab at the CPC

Has anyone brought up the issue about the 'helpers' not helping that much?

How the West’s ‘Sore Losers’ Hurt Canada, and Their Cause​


Rather than contributing to Poilievre’s “Canada First” vision, leaders like Alberta’s Danielle Smith and former Reform leader Preston Manning are pursuing regional defiance that threatens not only federal Conservative prospects but also the unity of the country itself.

Some conservative leaders in the West are refusing to do the hard work of building bridges across provinces. Instead, they are undermining national institutions, elevating regional grievances and offering what we might call performative disengagement. The tactic may win headlines and satisfy the base, but it weakens the broader conservative project at a critical moment in our country’s history.

 
Putting this out here now - April 9th - that food costs come August-October harvest times here in Canada are going to be markedly higher as a direct result of this little war in Iran. Virtually every single input cost that goes into growing anything will have spiked higher as a direct result of this war and there is NOTHING a Liberal or Conservative or NDP Federal Government could do to reduce this from happening.

Then cuts the taxes from all food and fuel products.

I know you're looking to get ahead and give your man top cover.
 
The Gov is basically profiteering of inflated prices. Cut the taxes.

If not this sits squarely in PMMCs lap IMHO.
We can’t afford to cut taxes. If anything we should be starting to heavily cut expenses and/or increase taxes.

Just cutting taxes right now would be a childish reaction. There is still bills to pay and we aren’t even remotely close to breaking even.
 
The Gov is basically profiteering of inflated prices. Cut the taxes.

If not this sits squarely in PMMCs lap IMHO.
That's the talking point yes.

Reality however-
-the cost of CFR is a regulatory burden, not a tax (now matter how often PP says it). Ending it today doesnt strip out the sunk cost of compliance infrastructure, or the price premium on inventories throughout the various stages of the supply chain. It would take months for that to trickle through to a price break at the pumps. Whether you like the policy or not in principle- tying its cancellation to immediate relief from the cancellation is innaccurate opportunism.

The excise tax- flat rate per litre and doesn't scale with prices, no windfall

That leaves the GST of 5%. In my neck of the woods gas has gone from 1.30 to 1.80. The GST portion of that has gone from 6.2 cents to 8.6 cents. Giving back that "windfall" doesnt move the needle on the price of gas.

Any material consumer gas relief needs to be called what it is: deficit funded transfers
 
We can’t afford to cut taxes. If anything we should be starting to heavily cut expenses and/or increase taxes.

Just cutting taxes right now would be a childish reaction. There is still bills to pay and we aren’t even remotely close to breaking even.

Im cool with that too, where should we start ?


Increase taxes eh...

Jason Bateman Cotton GIF
 
That's the talking point yes.

Reality however-
-the cost of CFR is a regulatory burden, not a tax (now matter how often PP says it). Ending it today doesnt strip out the sunk cost of compliance infrastructure, or the price premium on inventories throughout the various stages of the supply chain. It would take months for that to trickle through to a price break at the pumps. Whether you like the policy or not in principle- tying its cancellation to immediate relief from the cancellation is innaccurate opportunism.

The excise tax- flat rate per litre and doesn't scale with prices, no windfall

That leaves the GST of 5%. In my neck of the woods gas has gone from 1.30 to 1.80. The GST portion of that has gone from 6.2 cents to 8.6 cents. Giving back that "windfall" doesnt move the needle on the price of gas.

Any material consumer gas relief needs to be called what it is: deficit funded transfers

I am not sure what knot you tied there, I never was very good at it. I normally go with the tied lots method.

Anyways, cut the taxes on food and fuel.

Fuel isn't for me, I really could care less about the price of gas. I didn't buy V8 because I want to dread going to the pumps. But I know lots people around need that help.

Food, no food or water should be taxed period.
 
Im cool with that too, where should we start ?


Increase taxes eh...

Jason Bateman Cotton GIF
I am of the opinion we shouldn’t run deficits except in times of extreme emergencies (i.e. WWII, etc.). We can afford to have no deficit, our greed prevents us and punishes the future.

Raising taxes makes people care about overspending and demands accountability because people don’t like to pay. If we had no national debt we currently would have no deficit. Thats how bad it has gotten. Thats billions upon billions wasted in interest just selling out our children. We don’t even have anything to show for it.

As to where I would start cutting, my first place would be OAS. Shouldn’t be paying welfare to people making more money than me.
 
I am of the opinion we shouldn’t run deficits except in times of extreme emergencies (i.e. WWII, etc.). We can afford to have no deficit, our greed prevents us and punishes the future.

Raising taxes makes people care about overspending and demands accountability because people don’t like to pay. If we had no national debt we currently would have no deficit. Thats how bad it has gotten. Thats billions upon billions wasted in interest just selling out our children. We don’t even have anything to show for it.

I think its pretty apparent Canadians don't care about debt and deficits right now.

As to where I would start cutting, my first place would be OAS. Shouldn’t be paying welfare to people making more money than me.

I agree. How do we get the voting block of those collecting OAS to buy in ?

For a politician this all comes down to re-electability. They wont touch this until that cohort is less powerful.
 
I think its pretty apparent Canadians don't care about debt and deficits right now.



I agree. How do we get the voting block of those collecting OAS to buy in ?

For a politician this all comes down to re-electability. They wont touch this until that cohort is less powerful.

Sometimes being in power means doing unpopular but necessary things.
 
I am not sure what knot you tied there, I never was very good at it. I normally go with the tied lots method.

Anyways, cut the taxes on food and fuel.
Your exact words were "The Gov is basically profiteering of inflated prices. Cut the taxes."

I was pointing out that the actually "price profiteering" on the consumer end is minimal, and that 1:1 relief based on returning it would also be minimal.

Any absolute position that those taxes shouldn't exist is unrelated to the current Iran driven price spike, and leveraging a short-term surplus from revenue pool A (GST on oil) to permanently eliminate revenue streams B and C (Excise tax, GST on gas) is fiscally irresponsible.
 
Back
Top